Brennan v CSA, De Guzman v De Guzman

Brennan Calls Out the CSA

brenna---Scott-Pribyl

Jim Brennan has launched a scathing attack on the Canadian Soccer Association and national team coach Dale Mitchell. It seems Jimmy B is a little peeved that he didn't get a phone call to tell him he wasn't part of the upcoming squad to face Honduras and Mexico. John F. Molinaro has the scoop at CBC.ca. Here's a  couple of highlights from the Toronto captain's comments to the press yesterday:

"I spoke to officials here at Toronto FC, my family and friends, and decided that it was best that I step down from the national team while the current manager is in place"

"There are a few people who shouldn't be there, there are a few people on the bench who shouldn't be there. When this World Cup campaign is over, I think a lot of players will come out and say how they feel, but they can't right now because of the situation."

"I have all the time in the world for Stephen [Hart] and Nick [Dasovic] … [But] there are a couple of people in the organization that you think, 'should they really be there?'"

Be sure to click the link provided above because there's much more.

I've have some mixed feelings about this outburst. On one hand, I applaud any effort by a Canadian player to call out how crappy the set-up is at the CSA. There's only two ways we're ever going to see change to our soccer governing body. They are the following:

i) Players harshly criticize the powers-that-be to the media, who report on those criticisms and add their own columns and commentaries routinely to apply pressure. Awareness is a good way to get the ball rolling on total structural change to the game in this country.

ii) A storming of the CSA by a populous armed with pitchforks and torches.

No one wants to see that second option. So Brennan's comments - in my book - are welcome.

On the other hand - last time I checked - Canada's actually still in this thing, despite all the doom and gloom. Yeah, I don't really think they'll qualify. But I'm saying there's a chance.

                                               carrey

And if there still is a chance, it's not really the right time to throw the coach under the bus and perhaps further unsettle the squad - especially when he's getting criticism from almost every corner of the Canadian soccer media.  Perhaps waiting until they are mathematically eliminated would have been more helpful to the cause.

De Guzman vs De Guzman

de-guz

Hat tip to reader Kevin Smith for pointing out to me that Feyenoord and Deportivo La Coruna were drawn together in Group H of the UEFA Cup, because I sure of hell wouldn't have checked. In case you haven't figured it out yet, this means we could potentially see a Julian v Jonathan De Guzman battle.

Uefa.com took some time and wrote a little piece about the possibility.

Filed under: , , , , , , ,
Posted Oct 08 2008, 11:23 AM by Joe Ross

Comments

Gian-Luca wrote re: Brennan v CSA, De Guzman v De Guzman
on 10-08-2008 11:51 AM

I agree the timing is poor. If a player revolution happened right after the Mexico match I would have been fine with that as at least there would have been time to change things for the final three matches, but waiting until now isn't really going to change anything for the better. As you suggest, other then further unsettling the team when they should have nothing but winning on their minds, what is going to change between now and Saturday?

With year long wait to even appoint a coach in the first place, to the players complaining that they still want all the games in Montreal even after they saw what happened against Honduras, to the reports of the players partying at a night club in Montreal after the loss to Honduras while most supporters were too depressed to speak, to whatever it is that Mitchell has done to tick off the players...... so far this has been a textbook example of how not to run a World Cup Qualifying campaign from everyone involved. Please, please, please let things change with an actual Canadian win on Saturday.  

Pompey_Canuck wrote re: Brennan v CSA, De Guzman v De Guzman
on 10-08-2008 12:58 PM

I think that the reason for the timing is that as Brennan is no fan of Mitchell to begin with, to find out he was dropped from the side without so much as a phone call was too much for him.  

That said I do think the timing matters at all.  I do not think that we will qualify.  If Brennan and potentially other players feel this way about Mitchell then we are in a lot of trouble.  We need to fire Mitchell now.  We should have fired him after the loss to Honduras.

The way forward is to reorganize the CSA, fire the coach, and inform every player on the national team that is not going to be playing in 2014 that they are now retired, and get the younger players in the squad now, with the goal being to qualify for Brazil 2014.

The Footie Fool - » Brennan sticks it to CSA & Dale Mitchell wrote The Footie Fool - » Brennan sticks it to CSA & Dale Mitchell
on 10-08-2008 1:05 PM

Pingback from  The Footie Fool  -   » Brennan sticks it to CSA & Dale Mitchell

The Footie Fool - » Brennan sticks it to CSA & Dale Mitchell wrote The Footie Fool - » Brennan sticks it to CSA & Dale Mitchell
on 10-08-2008 1:05 PM

Pingback from  The Footie Fool  -   » Brennan sticks it to CSA & Dale Mitchell

ArupKumar wrote re: Brennan v CSA, De Guzman v De Guzman
on 10-08-2008 2:49 PM

Hey Joe, Love the Street fighteresque picture collage of the De Guzmans.

Brennan is one of the better players of the team and this move is not only a white flag but a blunder by the current CSA to attempt to push their rankings up. the current CSA is either non caring or just is plain incompetent

1: not legally qualified

2: inadequate to or unsuitable for a particular purpose

3 a: lacking the qualities needed for effective action b: unable to function properly

we need to make a mark in these qualifying games to gain some attention to our football association. I mean when countries in Africa where there is political turmoil are being run by good football heads why wouldn't they try to do the same in Canada? (yes I know, cash rules everything around me and the CSA doesn't give it out)

Kevin Smith wrote re: Brennan v CSA, De Guzman v De Guzman
on 10-08-2008 4:39 PM

What can I say, I'm observant :D

alex_ygd wrote re: Brennan v CSA, De Guzman v De Guzman
on 10-08-2008 7:26 PM

Joe, remember on the weekend when you asked the live blog if we thought England should cap Arteta?  Maybe Arteta's would look better in red and white... uh, the red and white with a maple leaf I mean.

Just sayin, everyone has their price.

anthony derbish wrote re: Brennan v CSA, De Guzman v De Guzman
on 10-08-2008 9:58 PM

joe ross pleaaaaaaaaase... everyone on the footy show is guilty of ripping mictchell and the csa at every opportunity...just the way i liek it... any time is a good time too speak out against this regine. yo and arup kumar......brennan is one of the better playerson the team? ya ok brennan dosnt do it fo rme. and change ur picture its stupid and has nothign to do with this blog

nima m wrote re: Brennan v CSA, De Guzman v De Guzman
on 10-08-2008 10:37 PM

fucking eh man, I love Brennan more and more each day!

Daveisonfire wrote re: Brennan v CSA, De Guzman v De Guzman
on 10-09-2008 2:09 AM

But there is only one De Guzman..

Pompey_Canuck wrote re: Brennan v CSA, De Guzman v De Guzman
on 10-09-2008 6:57 AM

I would say the match up is De Godman v De Dutchman

doctor.the.tardis wrote re: Brennan v CSA, De Guzman v De Guzman
on 01-04-2009 12:39 AM

I wanted to tell the Canadian football community this atrocity (sp?) that the CSA was pulling on foreign teams that were coming to Canada for friendly matches. I didn't know where else to submit this post other than under this CSA article.

Well living out here on the west coast of Canada, we have a little footy newspaper called the Soccer Paper. It published an article on the CSA's response to a Brazilian team coming to western Canada to play 5 friendly matches with local clubs.  I went to match between Gorge FC and AC Corintians in Victoria and overall...it was a really good match, both technically and entertaining. Everyone should read this article and see what the CSA is pulling.

soccerpaper.com/edition

To my horror, the CSA is out of control and I believe it is about time that the CSA gets a complete overhaul from the top down. Maybe then we can be viewed equal in the eyes of the footballing world. Until then, we will be always a mid-80 ranked team and a joke within CONCACAF.

Just to note...I am a Canadian soccer supporter and I don't like seeing this beloved game being treated this way within our country by a bunch of so called businessmen. Cheers.  

Add a Comment

(required )  
(optional )
(required )  
Remember Me?