Mitchell Fires Back/De Guzman Out/L'Impact Win Again

Mitchell Responds to Brennan Criticism

mitchell--karim-jafaar

Credit to our friend Neil Davidson from the Canadian Press for reporting on this story. I've noticed a few of the newspapers I've been surfing have edited the story's length, so be sure to read the full piece at CP's website because there's some juicy tidbits that didn't make the cut. Example:

"Mitchell was more definitive Wednesday when asked if he would ever summon [Jim] Brennan again.

'No,' he said.

Mitchell said Brennan had turned down the call-ups in the last 18 months 'but when he doesn't get a call-up then we get a big song and dance about it.' "

BOOM! I never even thought about that yesterday but, that's a damn good point from Mitchell. More from Davidson:

"Asked about the timing of Brennan's comments, Mitchell would only say: 'I don't think the timing of it (Brennan's comment) helps us, but that's Jimmy's decision. That's his call.' "

Mitchell also addresses his critics in the article linked above. It's well worth the read.

While these exchanges through the media aren't really productive, I will say this - it sort of makes Canadian soccer interesting for a change.

The Footie Fool has his take on the war of words, complete with a great headline "...and then it got pissy"

Oh yeah, and Julian De Guzman is Unavailable Due to Injury

de-guz---marc-serota

I've gotten so caught up in this entertaining war of words between Dale Mitchell and Jim Brennan that I haven't even had time to shit my pants at the thought of Julian De Guzman being unavailable for these next two matches. In that same Davidson CP article De Godzman's absence is confirmed, with Nik Ledgerwood being recalled in his place.

So that's no De Guzman for Honduras and Mexico, and no Dwayne De Rosario and no Adrian Serioux for just Honduras. I'm not holding my breath for a miracle.

Meanwhile, Some Positivity in Canadian Soccer

impact
Photo Courtesy of montrealimpact.com

It looks like there will be soccer in Montreal this February, as the Impact smoked Joe Public FC 4-1 in Trinidad. Eat that, Jack Warner. Oh and do you all remember this gem From Joe Public coach Keith Griffith back when the Impact downed them 2-0 in Montreal?

"The next time we meet the Impact at Marvin Lee (their stadium in Trinidad and Tobago), we'll beat them by four goals clear, for sure"

Anything to say to Keith, Nelson?

nelson_munce

Thought so.

Peter Mallett has a match report at globesports.com.

Out of Touch blogged the first half of the game, and posted a little round-up. Be sure to read his thoughts on Jim Brennan and the De Guzman injury as well, which are entertaining as always.

Duane Rollins at Out of Left Field says this result is just more proof that he doesn't know what he's talking about. Don't be so hard on yourself Duane. No one thought this was coming. At least, that's what I keep telling myself after dismissing their chances a few months ago.

Steven Sandor at The Full 90 contrasts the success of the Impact with the implosion of the National team.

And finally, Kartik Krishnaiyer at Major League Soccer Talk has posted his thoughts on the USL's performance on Matchday Four in CONCACAF. And he thinks...the league was humiliated!?! Montreal's performance sub-par? Kartik, I'm a big fan. Read the blogs, listen to the podcasts and the radio shows. And I know Joe Public are abject and all, but how can a 4-1 win on the road be classified as a humiliation for the USL? They can only beat the competition in front of them, and they did it with ease. However, I do take your point about the missed sitters - they will not get away with such sloppiness against superior opposition. 

Filed under: , , , , , ,
Posted Oct 09 2008, 09:49 AM by Joe Ross

Comments

alex wrote re: Mitchell Fires Back/De Guzman Out/L'Impact Win Again
on 10-09-2008 10:11 AM

I think you missed the best quote from Mitchell in the article:

"I think the negativity started after the first game against Jamaica (a 1-1 tie), which I was trying to convince people was a good performance"

Joe Ross wrote re: Mitchell Fires Back/De Guzman Out/L'Impact Win Again
on 10-09-2008 10:16 AM

Ha...yeah that one is pretty classic.

Pompey_Canuck wrote re: Mitchell Fires Back/De Guzman Out/L'Impact Win Again
on 10-09-2008 10:25 AM

I can't believe Dale Mitchell's remarks! Here is an exert from the linked article "Mitchell also suggested that some of the critics do not understand the sport at the highest level."  

If you want to talk to someone who doesn't understand the game at the highest level Dale Mitchell is a perfect example.  He has got to be fired, his job was to get Canada to the World Cup and he blew it big time.  

If Mitchell went to Mexico to lose which is what he tactics tell us, then why play the now suspended players?  What was the point?  If we sat them, then we could play them against Honduras in a match we need to win!  I don't understand his tactics, but that must be because I don't understand the game at the highest level.  

What about his team selection?  Lars Hirschfeld (now Canada's undisputed #1) was not selected because he was not getting first team action.  On the other hand Paul Stalteri is selected for every squad but is not even getting games on the reserves.  David Edgar didn't look great, but he was starting in the Premier League and he doesn't make the squad (Joe I would rather see McKenna in the Centre of Defence than Edgar, but it would make sense to have another centre half on the team so that Serioux can play in the midfield against Mexico) again. I don't understand the team selection at all, but that must be because I don't understand the game at the highest level.

As for the Brennan Fiasco, I think that the reason that Brennan is mad is partly because he was dropped, but mostly because he wasn't told about it.  I think that given the small number of players that have been regulars on the squad, it really isn't too much to call Brennan and say that you are going with another player, I mean he plays in Canada! It is not like it is going to be a hugely expensive long distance call.  It is the right thing  to do for someone who has been a part of the national set up for a long time.  As Brennan alluded to he and Mitchell don't see eye to eye on a lot of things so if Mitchell didn't tell Brennan and left him off the squad as a way to spite him then he shouldn't be surprised at the flack that he is getting.  I think that there are certainly more players that feel the way that Brennan feels, and there will be no shortage of criticism of Mitchell from the players once he is gone.  But that is probably because the players don't understand the game at the highest level.  

On to happier things the Impact with a great win over Jack Warner FC in Trinidad.  I agree Joe that it is fantastic result on the road and as for humiliating the USL?! I don't know what Kartik is on about?  Yes you have to score on nearly every chance when playing better opposition, but when Arsenal beat a team 6-0 and miss good chances along the way they don't embarrass the Premier League in the Process.  I think that the fact that a USL team has a huge lead in the Champions League is a source of Pride for the USL.  Everyone should remember that Jack Warner FC spanked the New England Revolution in New  England.  If there is any league that should be humiliated by their performance in the Champions League it is the MLS.  Well Done Impact!  Keep up the good work!  

Any chance of getting Limniatis on the podcast?

Joe Ross wrote re: Mitchell Fires Back/De Guzman Out/L'Impact Win Again
on 10-09-2008 10:45 AM

I'm not really sure about Limniatis. Sharman's producing now. Maybe he'll give it  a try.

Ossington Mental Youth wrote re: Mitchell Fires Back/De Guzman Out/L'Impact Win Again
on 10-09-2008 2:00 PM

I think you may have missed Kartik Krishnaiyers point, i think the league he was refering to was the MLS as opposed to USL (after all there is MLS in the title). It was in fact embarasssing for the MLS and sadly Garber is doing little to change it (or so it seems) in the next season as he says there will be no change in roster sizes, the schedule still will not accomodate Fifa and Superliga is still a priority. So pathetic and bushleague. Too bad he wont realize that competing in the likes of Concacaaf CL will allow for MLS teams to gain respect in Concacaaf and arguably even in south america...

Joe Ross wrote re: Mitchell Fires Back/De Guzman Out/L'Impact Win Again
on 10-09-2008 8:23 PM

I don't think so OMY.

the headline is "USL Gets Humiliated on Matchday Four in CONCACAF" and he writes

"The results were disasterous even with Santos resting several regulars. 3-0 (Puerot Rico Islanders loss) was the final scoreline which proves USL sides have neither the depth nor the quality to really compete against the best from North America."

and

"A very embarrasing performance and a revealing night that discredits some of the love USL has been getting lately. When you factor in Montreal’s sub par performance against a vastly outclassed Joe Public side, the worst team to make the group stage in the region, USL had a bad night."

Mark wrote re: Mitchell Fires Back/De Guzman Out/L'Impact Win Again
on 10-10-2008 12:38 PM

So... you guys don't understand the game according to Dale Mitchell??

I would have loved to hear that all of the press had said " O... you're right... see ya!" and then you all walked out of his press conference.

Would have served him right!

Ossington Mental Youth wrote re: Mitchell Fires Back/De Guzman Out/L'Impact Win Again
on 10-10-2008 2:40 PM

Joe-

It would seem youre right, i read the article a while back so my memory of details is vague unless of course i have it confused with another article.

That being said, sounds like the writer is delusional

Add a Comment

(required )  
(optional )
(required )  
Remember Me?