Two and a half years after they let him leave for New Orleans, the San Diego Chargers got an up-close look at Drew Brees Sunday. With Brees dominating the league (and the Chargers), you’d have to think the team’s thinking twice about their decision.
Three years ago, after the 2005 season, things were finally starting to come together for the San Diego Chargers. LaDainian Tomlinson was the best offensive player in football, Shawne Merriman was the defensive rookie of the year, and Drew Brees was a young and exciting quarterback who could lob balls towards Antonio Gates – the best tight end in the game.
Problem was, the Chargers had used a first-round draft pick on a new, highly-touted quarterback two years prior, and they weren’t about to let Philip Rivers waste away on the sidelines.
The rest is history. To summarize: Brees wasn’t re-signed in the offseason, partly because Rivers was waiting in the wings and partly due to what was considered to be a serious should injury, suffered in the final week of the regular season.
Brees went to New Orleans, where he’s become one of the most dangerous quarterbacks in the game. Rivers helped the Chargers to a 14-win season in 2006, making his only Pro Bowl in the process.
The two met Sunday, at a neutral site (London, England), and here’s what went down:
Brees: 30-for-41, 339 YDS, 3 TD
Rivers: 25-for-40, 341 YDS, 3 TD, INT
Brees had the edge, and his team got the win.
So, you have to wonder if the Chargers’ brass was watching this one thinking, What if?
What if San Diego had Brees under centre in the ’06 playoffs, rather than Rivers, who completed only 14 of 32 passes as the Chargers were upset by the Patriots?
What if the Chargers had used a more-experienced Brees that year, or in 2007, when they once again fell short against the Pats in the postseason?
Maybe Marty Schottenheimer, who was fired following the team’s 14-2 ’06 season, would still have a job. Maybe the Chargers would have a Super Bowl appearance or two under their belts.
Maybe. We’ll never know.
In hindsight, San Diego might’ve been better off trading Rivers, who was an extremely valuable commodity, strengthening a need (maybe wide receiver?) and keeping Brees, whose “prime” coincided with Tomlinson’s.
Now we’re watching Brees dominate, week in and week out, without a lot of support in New Orleans, where the defence is suspect and offensive contributors have been dropping like flies.
Brees is only 29 – two years older than Rivers. He’s on pace to break Dan Marino’s all-time single-season passing yards record.
This isn’t to downplay the positive things Rivers has done. He continues to be a top-end NFL quarterback. But sometimes too much stock is put into top draft picks. Brees gave the Chargers their best chance to win then, and he probably still would now.
But that ship has sailed. The Chargers can’t worry about Brees anymore. They had their look at him Sunday, and lost for the third time in four games.
You’d imagine that for at least a few moments, they sat back and thought … what if?
Week 8 one-liners
• One week after we questioned whether he was done, Tomlinson had his best game of the year.
• If he were the Patriots’ quarterback last season, we’re confident that Brees would have put up numbers equal to or better than those of Tom Brady.
• Think the Chargers aren’t missing Merriman? They haven’t registered a sack in nine quarters.
• Since the game in London was technically a Saints’ home game, the Chargers won’t play in New Orleans until 2016. That will mark the first game they’ve played there since 1997 – a 19-year hiatus from The Big Easy.
• The Raiders’ running game is lost without Darren McFadden.
• Random player we’d never heard of until this week: Chaz Schilens, who led all Oakland receivers Sunday, and who immediately reminded us of Will Ferrell’s character from Wedding Crashers.
• Joe Flacco is sneaky athletic.
• Tim Hightower, the apparent future of the Cardinals’ running game, is averaging 2.7 yards per carry. The onus is squarely on you, Kurt Warner.
• Don’t look for help from the defence, either. The Cardinals are averaging 25 points per game in losses this season.
• Once a touchdown king, Marion Barber has only one rushing touchdown since week 3.
• Sam Paulescu had the biggest tackle of the day for the Cowboys. Paulescu is the punter.
• The Buccaneers didn’t score a touchdown Sunday. That hadn’t happened since the first week of the 2006 season.
• Not sure what sounds worse: The Lions have now lost eight straight or the Lions have now lost 14 out of 15.
• Only once this season has Chad Pennington posted a single-game passer rating of less than 80. He’s gone over 100 in four of his seven games.
• Being a good fourth-quarter team isn’t always enough. Eventually, you’ll have a bad final frame and you’ll pay. That happened to the Bills Sunday.
• Donnie Avery is going to be an absolute star.
• Roddy White and Ted Ginn won’t be far behind.
• The difference in the Rams-Pats game: St. Louis was flagged for nine penalties; New England, zero.
• We never would have expected the Giants and Steelers to play that sloppy a game.
• Looking back, Sunday’s performance against the Giants was likely the worst game of Ben Roethlisberger’s career.
• David Garrard is back to his old self. That’s 151 pass attempts without an interception. He and Jason Campbell are the safest quarterbacks in football.
• Andre Johnson has pushed Terrell Owens and Randy Moss aside to become the best wide receiver in the NFL.
• Where the hell did that come from, Leonard Weaver?
• We’ve been saying all along that Shaun Hill is the better option in San Francisco. Finally, after half a season of embarrassment, the 49ers are realizing it, too.
• The Seahawks are back in the winner’s circle. Great news, right? It comes in teaspoons for Seattle fans, who are now hoping Lofa Tatupu won’t miss extended time.
Blatant overreaction of the week
“The Chargers are done!”
Yeah, it’s been a rough first half and, sure, the defence can’t stop anyone. But the Chargers are lucky to be in a division that is still winnable. The Broncos have their own defensive problems, while the Raiders and Chiefs just aren’t in the race. Amazingly, San Diego is only a game and a half out in the AFC West.
Why the (Carolina Panthers) will win Super Bowl XLIII
They’re an annual fad pick ever since losing to the Patriots in the Super Bowl a few years back, but they never deliver. But, at 6-2, it’s time to start recognizing that with Jake Delhomme healthy, the defence solid as always, and the running game hot, these guys could play deep into January.
And, as always, it’s important to remember that they’ve been there before.
Why the (Buffalo Bills) won’t win Super Bowl XLIII
Are the Bills this year’s early-season flame that is now being doused (think: ’07 Lions)? It’s possible. Marshawn Lynch continues to have a mediocre season, while Trent Edwards is one of the slowest starters in the league. It won’t be easy to keep up in the AFC.
Team of the week: New York Giants
It wasn’t pretty, but a big win in Pittsburgh helps the Giants keep a leg up on the rest of the NFC. This defence knows how to step up when needed; five more sacks on Sunday were proof of that. It wouldn’t be out of line to call the Giants one of the best road teams in NFL history.
Player of the week: Mathias Kiwanuka
It’s hard not to give this to Brian Westbrook, who got the Eagles back on track in his return to the lineup against the Titans, but Kiwanuka keyed a great performance from the Giants’ defence, sacking Roethlisberger three times. Kiwanuka, who also had three pressures on Roethlisberger, picked up two of his sacks in the fourth quarter and forced a fumble. Who needs Osi Umenyiora?
Setting the pace
• Brees is on pace to pass for 5,126 yards, breaking Dan Marino’s single-season record.
• Heading into tonight’s game, LenDale White is on pace to score 21 touchdowns.
• If Andre Johnson keeps doing the average of what he’s done the last four weeks for the remainder of the season, he’ll catch an NFL-record 148 passes for an NFL-record 2,106 yards.
• Joey Porter is on pace to register 24 sacks, breaking Michael Strahan’s single-season record.
MVP watch
We’ll be watching Albert Haynesworth closely tonight, but in the meantime, we’ll give the MVP to Brees, who leads the league in passing yards (he’s almost 500 yards ahead of the next-best guy). His 101.6 passer rating helps. Our only concern at this point: Brees’ seven interceptions.
Rookie of the Year watch
As of right now, your offensive rookie of the year is Titans running back Chris Johnson, who’ll try to bolster his hold on the award tonight. Your defensive rookie of the year is Chiefs cornerback Brandon Flowers, who broke out with two big picks and a touchdown against the Jets.
Ray Edwards single-season sack record watch
Edwards, the little-known Vikings defensive end, said in the offseason he planned on breaking Michael Strahan’s single-season sack record of 22.5. We’ll track his progress here each week.
The Vikes were off this week. Tune in next week to see if Edwards can pick up his first full sack of the season.