It was an exciting day, with some wild games that came down to the wire. OK, maybe not. But there were still some things we took away from Thanksgiving Thursday. Allow us to elaborate.
• As soon as the Titans-Lions game got into the fourth quarter, we wondered aloud (but to ourselves) if we’d finally see Vince Young. After all, he is the backup quarterback and it’s pretty much courtesy for teams to bring in their backups with big leads in the final frame.
But Young, of course, is no ordinary backup. First, he’s undoubtedly more athletic and arguably more talented than Kerry Collins (notice we didn’t say, “more effective,” or “better”). Second, there’s sort of a shaky history that has led to the 2006 third-overall draft pick being a backup in the first place.
Would Jeff Fisher be risking opening a can of worms by bringing Young in for mop-up duty? What if Young was fantastic? What if he was bad? Would being the caretaker on national television embarrass the ’06 rookie of the year?
It was a bigger decision than you would imagine for Fisher. You stick with Collins and you’re showing an increased lack of faith in Young and proving that his “backup” title is nothing more than that … a title. You go to Young and you risk opening said can of worms.
It worked out just fine. Young looked good, but was mainly just handing the ball off anyway. And now the Titans know they have two legitimate options at quarterback.
------------------------------
• We’ve been thinking about this for weeks, but are finally able to deliver a definitive verdict on what we think of most NFL colour commentators: Generally, they seem to be significantly stupider (it’s a word) than the general population.
No, we’re not being that fan who whines because a colour guy is somehow “biased” against his team. We mean this genuinely: Colour commentators, for the most part, aren’t very smart human beings.
There’ve been more than a few examples of analyst density over the last few weeks, but we’ll just give you the example that confirmed our suspicions on Thursday.
The Seahawks are in the red zone, trailing by 18 early in the third quarter. A touchdown would be great, of course, but when you’re down three scores, the key is getting it to two scores. You need to score three times anyway.
And then Fox’s Troy Aikman says that this “would be a wasted possession” if Seattle had to settle for a field goal.
Wasted possession? Is this guy nuts? Points are points, especially when they bring you to within two scores. A wasted possession, Troy, would be if Matt Hasselbeck threw one to Terence Newman, not settling for a field goal.
And it got better. After Hasselbeck missed Bobby Engram on third down and the field goal team came marching out, Aikman added that Seahawks coach Mike Holmgren “hesitated” before deciding to settle for three points.
No coach -- not even the ultra-aggressive Sean Payton -- would pass up the automatic points in a situation like that. We’re guessing Aikman wasn’t listening in on Holmgren’s conversation with his offensive coordinator at that moment in time. We’re thinking he simply thought going for it, in his wacky world, was a good idea, and gave it more credence by claiming a head coach with 17 years’ experience was thinking the exact same thing.
We’re betting he wasn’t.
Simple reasoning, common sense and the ability to do basic math -- just some of the tools a colour guy should have. Because a lot of football fans are smart, and it’s obvious when the guy preaching on the screen is lagging.
Aikman, Randy Cross and Ron Jaworski might know X’s and O’s, but they don’t seem to have a grasp on the simple stuff, and it grinds our gears. Unfortunately, Chris Collinsworth can’t do every game.
------------------------------
• Are you seriously telling us the Arizona Cardinals couldn’t use Edgerrin James right now? Not utilizing James, for what seems to be nothing more than a grudge mixed with some spite, has been the single biggest mistake the Cards have made this season.
Arizona’s lost back-to-back big games, mainly because it hasn’t been able to get things going on the ground.
In Thursday’s loss to the Eagles, Tim Hightower ran the ball seven times for only seven yards.
James had zero carries.
In last week’s loss to the Giants, Hightower ran the ball 11 times for only 21 yards.
James had one carry.
Arizona won the week before that, but no thanks to Hightower, who had 11 carries for 35 yards.
James had one carry.
Headed into Thursday night’s game, no starting running back had a lower yards per carry number than Hightower’s 3.0. No one’s even close.
James hasn’t been much better, but it couldn’t hurt to at least mix things up. Right now, defences barely have to worry about Arizona’s run game, which in turn is hurting the passing game.
------------------------------
• Of course it never helps when the team’s best player, Anquan Boldin, drops two passes and fumbles the game away when they still had life in the fourth quarter.
We would’ve been surprised to see stuff like that from Boldin after he returned from his face demolition surgery a few weeks ago, but there didn’t appear to be an excuse on Thursday.
Boldin’s been talked about here and there (mainly here) as an MVP dark horse. That went out the window against Philadelphia.
------------------------------
• Philly fans are considered to be a knowledgeable batch, but even they can’t refrain from whining every time a pass down the sideline falls incomplete.
Do people not believe in good coverage whatsoever? Every time you see a ball go down the left or right sideline, if there’s a receiver and corner in the area, it has to be either a catch or pass interference.
The receivers themselves are bad enough at committing this crime (yes, we consider it to be a crime), but we wish fans would be a little more attentive in this regard. Respect a good play by a cornerback or safety, and keep quiet.
But, naturally, we don’t expect a change. Just like every time a pitcher turns and fires to second base in baseball, we expect at least a smattering of boos every time a defensive player makes a good play on a deep ball.
------------------------------
• It was refreshing to see the officials actually call intentional grounding the way it should be called on Thursday night. Donovan McNabb was guilty on both infractions he was whistled for against the Cardinals.
Fans probably had the right to be a bit frustrated, because, let’s face it, quarterbacks get away with plays like that more often than not. But they actually got it right in both of these cases.
Still, there are two or three passes every game that are “in the vicinity of a receiver” that are truly blatant examples of the quarterback throwing the ball away to avoid incurring the loss of yardage that comes with a sack.
This offseason, the league needs to re-examine the way the rule is interpreted.
------------------------------
• It looks like NFL Network picked up that “Puddin’ Pie” for the player of the game at a local Baskin Robbins. If they want to be viewed on level with CBS and Fox, we need to see a more impressive Thanksgiving-related dish and/or trophy.